LOGAN — By all accounts, The Scarlet Pimpernel is a rarity on Utah stages—but Music Theatre West makes a compelling case that it should be far more common. The musical with book and lyrics by Nan Knighton and music by Frank Wildhorn is adapted from a novel of the same name. With soaring ballads, thrilling intrigue, comedic flair, and heart-stopping action, this production brings the beloved Baroness Orczy story to vivid life.
Set during the bloody height of the French Revolution, The Scarlet Pimpernel tells the story of Sir Percy Blakeney—a seemingly foolish English aristocrat who secretly leads a double life as a daring hero. Under the alias of “The Scarlet Pimpernel,” Percy and his band of comrades execute daring rescues of French nobility from the guillotine, leaving only a flower-inscribed calling card as a clue. The tale is often cited as a precursor to Zorro, Batman, and Superman—with Percy pioneering the archetype of the nobleman-by-day, vigilante-by-night.
But this isn’t just a story of swordplay and escape artistry—it’s a deeply human drama of love, betrayal, and loyalty. At its core is the fractured relationship between Percy and his wife Marguerite, an actress torn between the ideals of her homeland and the questioned devotion to her marriage. Add in the menacing and obsessive Citizen Chauvelin, a French official and scorned ex-lover of Marguerite, and you’ve got a riveting triangle of trust, manipulation, and mistaken loyalty.
Dallin Clark’s portrayal of Percy is nothing short of masterful. He transitions effortlessly between the flamboyant, fashion-obsessed buffoon and the commanding, battle-ready hero. His comedic timing is razor sharp—especially in scenes with Chauvelin and also with his League of the Scarlet Pimpernel, where his over-the-top posturing and witty banter earn genuine laughs. Yet it’s in songs like “Prayer” and “She Was There” where Clark’s emotional depth and powerful voice truly shine.
Patrice Densley Weatherston is radiant as Marguerite, delivering an aching vulnerability in “When I Look at You” and later bringing the house down with the heartbreaking “I’ll Forget You.” Her chemistry with both Percy and Chauvelin anchors the show’s emotional arc.
The Scarlet Pimpernel plays through June 28th at the Ellen Eccles Theatre in Logan, Utah. Photo by Shanda Lynn Call.
Nathan Scott’s Chauvelin is a commanding presence, wielding his voice like a weapon in “Falcon in the Dive” and the haunting “Where’s the Girl.” He’s more than a villain—he’s a man torn between personal vengeance and patriotic duty, making him both terrifying and tragically human. And wow, can Scott sing! He ends each solo with such powerful, soaring notes that seem to go on forever.
James Thatcher gives a rousing supporting performance as Marguerite’s brother, Armand. Unfortunately, we only get a small glimpse of Doyle’s beautiful voice when he sings the reprise of “You Are My Home” with Weatherston. Their harmony was breathtaking.
Percy’s always-hilarious “band of brothers” lit up the stage in their flamboyant pastels, delivering one of the evening’s standout moments. Their performance of “The Creation of Man”—complete with fluttering handkerchiefs, feathered hats, and delightfully over-the-top choreography—was a comedic showstopper. The entire ensemble’s energy was electric as they opened the show with the goose-bump inducing “Madam Guillotine.”
Directors Clifton and Melinda Richards have crafted a production that feels both intimate and grand, aided by the rich vocal direction of Karen Tuescher and dynamic choreography from Amber Freestone and Holden Matthews. The live orchestra is nothing short of spectacular, infusing the show with energy and elegance throughout.
The production makes inspired use of the Ellen Eccles Theater‘s gorgeous architecture —including its balconies—for both staging and dramatic tension. Costumes, designed by Emma Lovan, dazzle, especially in numbers like “Vivez” and the ball scenes, and the authentic-looking guillotine and fight choreography add cinematic thrills.
Cast of The Scarlet Pimpernel directed by Clifton and Melinda Richards. Photo by Shanda Lynn Call.
Beyond the adventure, The Scarlet Pimpernel explores weighty themes—loyalty to self versus country, personal integrity versus public duty, and the cost of keeping secrets. Marguerite and Percy’s broken trust is heartbreakingly real, and the question, “Can I trust you?” becomes a quiet refrain throughout. Even Chauvelin wrestles with conflicting loyalties—to France, to Marguerite, and to his own ego.
The Scarlet Pimpernel himself represents humility and quiet heroism—risking everything without seeking recognition. His moniker, taken from a humble English flower, becomes a symbol for inner strength hidden behind frivolous disguise.
The Scarlet Pimpernel is that rare production which entertains as much as it moves. With its sweeping score, charismatic leads, intricate plot, and unforgettable visuals, Music Theatre West has delivered one of the most thrilling shows of the summer. It’s a story of sacrifice, redemption, and the power of love—and it’s executed with polish, passion, and heart.
